Showing posts with label residency. Show all posts
Showing posts with label residency. Show all posts

Sunday, March 16, 2014

My Day As A Patient

For months now I have wanted to spend a day as a patient. I work at an adolescent Residential Treatment Center, and I'm trying to find more ways to understand what these kids go through.
I've starting reading the books they read, imagining myself in their shoes, and now, I finally had a chance to live (more or less) like a patient for one day.


I knew that the staff and all the kids would know who I was.  They would treat me differently.  There was no real way around that... but I could still make it as real as possible.

I followed all the rules: No belt, no shoelaces (just a zip-tie), no ring on my finger, no hat, etc…
I arrived at the treatment center about 6 am, used my keys to walk through the 4 locked doors to get to the patient hallway.  Then I went to the nurses station and the staff lockers.  I put my bag inside, then my phone. I hesitated before putting my keys in there.
I knew the staff would let me out at any moment. I could even order them if I wanted.  I’M A DOCTOR!  But that still didn’t change the feeling of helplessness when I put my keys in the locker, closed it, and walked through the auto-locking door onto the patient hallway.

I couldn’t get out on my own.  I had no access.  No keys. No phone.  It suddenly felt very real.  I walked down to my assigned room, and waited for the morning to start.
I first learn how boring the morning is, and how many times you get woken up.  First they shine a flashlight on you every 15 minutes during the night to make sure you are still in bed, alive, and not hurting yourself or trying to commit suicide. Then the phlebotomist wakes up anyone who needs their blood drawn for labs that have been ordered. (likely by me)
Then we get woken up again by the sound of “med-pass” when all the kids who take morning medications have to go to the nurse one by one, take their pills, swallow, open their mouths and move their tongues all around to show that they really swallowed and didn’t “cheek” the pill. 
Then it’s shower time.  I have to push the button every 25 seconds to keep the hot water coming, and there is no bathroom door or shower door – there are curtains only.  The curtains are only held up by Velcro, so you couldn't use them to hang yourself.
I can’t look out the windows – the shades are drawn between the double panes of glass.  The windows are also nigh unto bullet proof.  The beds, tables and cabinets are also bolted to the floor and thoroughly caulked to leave no sharp edges.  Oh – and the hangers for your clothes can only hold about 5 pounds before they “release” so you can’t hang yourself from them either.  (This place is very “safety” minded.)

We line up for breakfast.  "FACE FORWARD" is yelled and I quickly learn to be an arm's distance apart from the person in front of me and behind me.  No talking, no turning around.  Two staff members walk us through 3 locked doors to get to the cafeteria.
"SPECIAL DIET TO THE LEFT, GENERAL DIET TO THE RIGHT."

I am told I can take fruit, juice, milk, or oatmeal – but I follow the other kids lead and take 4 mini-boxes of cereal like everybody else.
We sit at assigned table.  No “cross-talking” means I only get to talk to kids at my own table.  We eat cereal and chat about life, music, who has which doctor, whose therapist is boring, whose parents are giving up custody, and which girls are hottest.
One kid has already been assigned to sweep the cafeteria and another to clean off the tables.  After 15 minutes the ‘upper level” kids get to have seconds.  If you’re new like me, you’re the last to get seconds, which means you have no time to eat.  You have to quickly line up to dump your tray. When I get to the trash can I am told to hold out my utensils and drop them in so the staff can see I didn’t pocket a plastic fork or spoon (that could be used to cut myself or someone else.)  Then I dump my trash, put my plate and tray through the slot in the wall, and go back to the unit and get ready for school.

Again, face forward, eyes ahead, arm’s length away from the person in front of me.

Time for school!  I go to class.  Up first is a 30 question Spelling/Vocabulary test based on the 5000 words most used on the SAT exam.  I look around.  2 kids are actually doing the quiz.  3 are ignoring the paper entirely.  1 is asking questions non-stop for 5 minutes and driving the teacher insane.  I’m trying to figure out the definition of “Aeronaut.”

Back to the patient hallway for “Sunrise.”  I hear the gong, then have 12 seconds of “mindful breathing” before I learn the skills for the day.  “Radical Acceptance” and “Big Picture” are selected, and then we recite the DBT Pledge.  (It’s actually quite nice, and most of the other patients have it memorized.)

We talk about who has what assignments in the Cafeteria and in the halls.  Then it’s back to school for 2 more classes.

I watch CNN Student News and take a 15 question quiz on it.  Next class is all about Tsunami’s and after a long quiz we watch the first 20- minutes of the movie “The Impossible.”  Pretty scary stuff.  Most the kids paid attention to that one.

Lunch!  Beef stroganoff. and blue Powerade - it was either drink that  that or caffeine free diet sodas.  The foam cups were small so my drink was gone pretty quick.  I started to stand to get a refill and the kids quickly told me to sit back down and raise my hand.  Permission must be asked before getting out of your seat.

So I asked  - DENIED.  No drink refills allowed until "seconds" is called, which would be near the end of the meal.

Confession - I was getting sick of the rules at this point.  Seriously.  They seemed arbitrary and unhelpful.
So I waited till no staff were looking and then refilled my Powerade.  The kids looked at me shocked like this was quite the coup - then they told on me and I got put on "freeze" at which point I was sent back to my bedroom to fill out paperwork about my disobedience.  I had to write out a "behavior chain" listing what happened, what led to my infraction, how I felt, when I I could have changed, the pros and cons of my actions - and what committed action I was going to take in the future.

Then time for gym.  Outside - basketball court, large sand area, and picnic tables.

20 kids sat at the tables immediately and looked like they weren't going to do anything.  I picked up a basketball and asked who wanted to play.  Five boys decided to play and we had a serous game of 3 on 3 basketball for about an hour.

For the entire hour we played and sweated and laughed and struggled, while 20 other kids sat and did nothing.

(No wonder the kids here gain weight - if you take psych meds, eat tons of carbs all day long, and don't exercise - you're going to pack on the pounds fast)

The afternoon was the most useful.  Therapy groups!

DBT skills, mindfullness, being able to tolerate strong emotions.  How to live a life worth living, how to move forward living your values no matter what situation you are in.  It was impressive to watch the therapist teach and demonstrate all the coping skills for an hour.  He was speaking to a room full of teenage girls who cut themselves, constantly threaten suicide, have eating disorders, have been abandoned, were sexually abused, and are addicted to multiple drugs.

He was able to connect with each of them, squelch arguments, build relationships, and chip away at the  harsh exterior a lot of these girls present.

The next therapy group was "Job Skills."  All the girls had already learned about job applications, resumes, how to prepare for an interview, and to day was "mock interview day."


They were supposed to pretend they were being interviewed for a job at Subway.  I worked at Subway of and on for 5 years.  I had been through that interview, and had interviewed others myself.


It was a great class as I was allowed to be the interviewer and help these girls learn how to present themselves, how to answer, what to mention, what to leave out.  I felt like it was a very practical class, and very useful.


Then came the best meeting - SUNSET.  The whole hallway got together and discussed what they did well and what needed improvement that day.  They talked about what skills they used, when they failed, and what they want to do differently tomorrow.  Those who had offended others made a public apology and made a commitment, stating what they would do differently in the future.  


Dinner was much the same as the other meals.


Then room time alone to work on things we hadn't finished during the day.   We were told to write out one more behavior chain about something that had happened that day. What led up to it, how we felt, what our "primary emotion" was and what our "secondary emotion" was as well.

Then it was time to let the kids relax.  Friday night - movie or dance party.  My hallway chose dance party.  So out came the Xbox Kinect and "Just Dance" and for the next 90 minutes we danced and sang and laughed and joked while the techs gave us hot chocolate.  Some kids went and did Yoga in a side room, others went to watch an episode of "Heroes."


Me - I danced and joked and laughed and had a blast.  I saw that this was the time for the kids to use everything they learned in a more natural setting.  Be themselves.  Have fun with friends.  Make mistakes and screw up and just laugh it off and keep dancing.

When 8:30 finally came it was time for bed.  Lights out on the hallway. 
The kids saw me walking toward the nurses station and said "Hey, you getting discharged?"
"Yeah - one day.  Must be a record!" I called back.

The nurses opened the door for me.  I'd like to say I got my stuff and went home, but there were orders to sign and a few kids who needed to be seen by a doctor really quick before I went home for the night.
I was completely exhausted.  I didn't even bother to put my shoelaces back in - I went home wearing zip-ties.

One day.  14 hours as a patient.  I see how residential treatment can help.  I also see how it can drive you up the wall, make you want to scream, and leave you overweight and out of shape when you leave after 90 days.
I can see how it seems pointless at times.  I felt a little bit of the helplessness these kids must feel, and that was even knowing that I wasn't REALLY locked in there.

How would it be to spend 90 days there? How about 180 days like some kids I've seen?  Or worse - be told you're going to Disneyland with a short stop on the way and then find out your parents lied to you and they've admitted you to a locked psychiatric facility?  (It's happened multiple times)

I still don't know what's it's like to be one of them.  But if I've gained even an ounce of empathy for these kids - it was well worth the 14 hours that day.

Friday, November 16, 2012

The Nobel Prize that Keeps Affecting My Life


Doctor's graduate from medical school every year - but not all of them will practice medicine.  Thousands of them will never get the chance.
CNN wrote a great article entitled: Why your waiter has an MD that explains the problem.

Here's the gist of it:
All med-school graduates who want to practice in the USA have to complete a "Residency Training Program."  If you want to specialize in anything such as Anesthesia, Psychiatry, OB/GYN, Family Practice, Surgery etc… you need to complete a 3-5 year residency and then pass your specific specialty board exams.  After that you can do EVEN MORE training called a “fellowship” to be a sub-specialist; such as a vascular surgeon, a child psychiatrist, or a pediatric oncologist. 

There are a few problems with this system.

In 2012 :
38,377 doctors applied to residency training programs in the United States:  there are only
24,034 slots available.

1st – 14,000 doctors who graduated from medical school and passed their general medical boards – will not be able to practice in the USA because they didn’t get into a residency.

2nd – How do you decide who goes to which residency?  Let’s say I wanted to be a dermatologist.  I applied to 45 different dermatology residencies.  I interview at 8 of them. 
Those 8 programs have interviewed anywhere from 15 to 100 applicants.  Every residency wants the best applicants, and every applicant wants the best program (or sometimes any program).

What is the best way to decide who goes to which residency?  Everyone knows you (the applicant) are interviewing at 7 other places - and you know they are interviewing another 50 people for the spot you want.  Who picks?  If you aren't picked by your top choice - do you then apply late to your second choice?

How do you make it fair and most advantageous for all parties involved?

SWITCH GEARS!
A while ago I read the book “A Beautiful Mind” – the biography of John Forbes Nash.   I blogged about it because it was interesting and insightful - and I got to see the life of a genius with schizophrenia.  There was an entire chapter devoted to his mentor – Lloyd Shapely.
Shapely was a genius of game theory. 
(He and John Nash and two others even invented their own game called “So Long Sucker.”)
Shapely did a lot of theoretical mathematics in game theory – like figuring out how to give the best result for all players when everyone is competing against each other.

 – Which brings us back to the problem of 38,000 doctors applying for 24,000 residency slots.
Let’s say one residency can accept 2 applicants per year.  They interview 20 candidates each year and then rank those 20 doctors from first choice to last choice.
Those applicants have interviewed at 15 different residency programs, and have ranked them from first choice to last choice.

How do you match them up?  How do you make sure that after you’ve weeded through 38,000 applicants applying to 4,427 residency programs offering 24,000 slots – that every had the best result?
How do you make sure that there is not a residency and an applicant that would both prefer each other over what they ended up with?
Let’s say Stanford Dermatology has 3 slots.
I ranked them as my #1 choice, and I am their #20 choice.
I ranked UCLA as my #2 choice and I am their # 5 choice.
I ranked Texas as my #3 choice and I am their #2 choice.

Where do I go?  Do I go to Texas because it's the best match?  Just becuase the combined ranking score at Texas (3+2) is less than UCLA (2+5) or Stanford(1+20)?  What if Stanford’s top 19 picks ranked some place else as their #1? Do I become Stanford's #1 pick because I'm the only guy left who really wants them?
Whose list takes precedence?  Does Stanford send out 3 letters of acceptance, wait to see if they get rejections, and then try to fill the slots with the next 3 people on their list?

There is a system called the National Resident Matching Program (NRMP).  It’s designed to take every applicants rank list, and every residency programs rank list – and match them up. The applicants choice is considered first, then the Residency's.

Many applicants think - Can I beat the system?  How can I get into a better program than I’m really qualified for?  Could I rank programs at the top of my list that I have no chance of getting into – and then hope that the system will feel sorry for me and give me the first program I have a shot at (which is my REAL 1st choice but I ranked it low to game the system?)

You may think I’m kidding.  I’m not.  I had friends in medical school trying to play this game with their training sites and med-school rotations.  They tried to beat the system, to play the game.
Luckily – the Matching system (NRMP) is based on Shapely’s theories about game theory.
A man named Alvin E. Roth proved that the NRMP was both stable and strategy-proof.  It gave everyone the best possible outcome, and it was impossible to “win the game” or “beat the system” by some strategy.

It is in everyone’s best interest to be completely honest in their rankings.  You have the best chance of getting your 1st choice, and so on down the list.  It is true for the applicant, it is true for the residency.
This seems to make perfect sense – but how hard was it to make that system?  How do you allow for so many variables.

Some residencies only have 1 slot, some have 20.  Some applicants only rank 1 program, some rank 30?
That is why Shapely and Roth are winning the Nobel Prize this year.  Their combined efforts have developed a perfect system.  It can’t be beaten, tricked, swindled, twisted, or played.  Everyone uses the exact same strategy.

3 years ago I applied to 10 programs.  I interviewed at 5 programs and made my "rank list."  On “Match Day” every graduating medical student found out where they were working for the next few years.  I found out I was moving to Reno, my first choice.

2 months ago I applied for a “sub-specialty fellowship.”  I interviewed last month.  I submitted my “rank list” last week.

January 9th 2013 is “Match Day.” It’s the day I find where I’m training for the next 2 years (if I matched at all).
December 8th 2012 is the Nobel Prize Ceremony.  That’s the day that Roth and Shapely will give their Nobel Lectures.  I’ll be listening, and silently thanking them for making my life, education, and career - much easier.

To Dr. Roth and Dr. Shapely – thank you.


P.S. (Random Fact) - The Nobel Prize in Economics is not actually a Nobel Prize.   There are Nobel Prizes in Physics, Chemistry, Physiology/Medicine, Literature, and Peace.
It's actually awarded by the Central Bank of Sweden and is called "The Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel"

Monday, October 15, 2012

Studying For Tests: My Two Decades of Evolving Study Techniques

Last week I took the PRITE exam.  (Psychiatry Resident In Training Exam)

I still have more tests to take in the future: Child Psychiatry Board Exam, General Psychiatry Board Exam, etc...
I may be a doctor, but I only got here by becoming an expert test taker first.  Which means I had to learn how to study.
I am not the smartest or best test taker by far.  I did not glide through medical school, and I was not in the top of my class.  I worked hard, constantly evolving my study skills to meet the latest challenge.  Here is my journey.


ELEMENTARY SCHOOL

 - I almost never studied.  It was so bad that when there were spelling tests and two words were pronounced the same (red, read) I'd have to ask the teacher to use the word in a sentence because I had never looked at the list.
I only studied when there was a competition.  When I was in a Geography competition I spent hours and hours at home memorizing all the countries.

HIGH SCHOOL
 - I studied a little for classes, but I knew there was one test that mattered most: The ACT.  I checked all the colleges I wanted to go to - and figured out what ACT and GPA I would need for a scholarship.  My GPA would take consistent work - but the ACT was a single test with HUGE results.  That's why I needed to figure out how to take it.  I took it my freshman year - I didn't get the score I wanted.
I took a review course and took it my sophomore year - still too low.  I took it again my Junior year - too low.  I took another review course and then took it again my junior year - 1 point too low.
I took it for the fifth time my Senior Year - NAILED IT!

I earned the scholarship I needed to be able to pay for college, and off I went.

COLLEGE
 - This is where I learned the necessity of study groups.  I walked into a physics class and quickly discovered - I didn't get it.  I could go to lecture and read the book and it still made no sense.  So about the 2nd week of class I paid attention to who was bored, but always knew the answer.  Two guys in the front (Jake and Pete) were always joking together, but when the teacher called on them - they answered everything right.
I walked up to them after class and asked if I could study with them. 
They already had a study room reserved 3 days a week at the same time for the whole semester.
All 3 of us aced Physics.
I then took Calculus.  I couldn't find a good study group so I went to the math tutoring center.  I sat there every afternoon for 4 months.  I used the same tutor every time.  He got paid by the school, I learned calculus, and thanks to him I aced that course.
Then came Genetics, Anatomy, Physiology, Organic Chemistry, Evolution, Pathophysiology, etc...
That's when I found my perfect study partner - Kyle.
He was more "bookish" than I was.  I knew the lectures.  I knew what the teachers liked, what topics they cared about and what lecture facts they were most likely to test.
Kyle new the book.  He knew the concepts, the underlying theory.  We sat in study rooms and wrote on white board for hours and hours - recreating metabolic pathways and memorizing names, equations, and formulas.  If not for him, I never would have passed those classes.
For a "pre-med" there is one test that determines the rest of your life: The MCAT.
It is the test to get into medical school.  I couldn't just take it 5 times to get the score I needed, because med school's don't just get your top score, they get all your scores.  They want someone who took it once and nailed it.
So - I decided to study for 1 year with a group of eight guys.
We took the formal practice exam nine months before the real thing.  We all scored too low.  We then met EVERY Saturday and practiced.  We reviewed practice questions, took practice tests, quizzed each other, wrote practice essays.  We worked, and worked, and worked.  One year later - I had my high score, and I was accepted at multiple medical schools.

MEDICAL SCHOOL
 - This is where I learned the art of note taking and an exact / never changing schedule.  By this time I was married with a child and I would have two more children before the end of medical school.  I needed family time, and I needed it to be dependable and predictable.
So I car-pooled with three classmates.  We left at 6:30 a.m. and came home at 5:30 p.m.  Whether we had classes or not - we were at school for 11 hours a day.  Saturday mornings I spent at the library from 9-12... always.
I learned that there was WAY too much material to review.  I needed one place to put all the pertinent information.  ONE page of notes for each test.
My first year the page looked like this:

By second year it looked like this:

I had to have a faster way to review, and to know what was important for the test.
We had study groups every day.  We always got together the night before a test to review again.  We always invited our friend Joel (the smartest guy in the class who lived near us) to join us.  He would give us the info we never thought to learn.  He would know the answers to questions no one had asked, and no one cared about...except the professor.  I learned enough to pass from my study group, I learned enough to do WELL from Joel.
When the 11 hours got too boring - I found a way to make studying more fun.  When studying anatomy I purchased flash cards with every muscle, bone, artery, vein, and organ labeled.  I'd place the cards all around the edge of  a pool table - and start a game.  Every shot I took - I'd memorize everything on the card under the cue before I took the next shot.  My games of pool took a long time - but I aced my anatomy tests.
I also learned to relax and recoup.  After EVERY test, we'd play basketball.  About 15 guys showed up every time, and we'd play for an hour or two. (you have to do something to stay sane.)

In medical school, there is a test that MUST be passed to go to residency -  the General Medical Boards.(USMLE or COMLEX)  It's actually three tests, each about one year apart, hundreds of questions, hundreds of dollars to take each.
I studied for each one for six months.  I bought the books, I listened to the review lectures, I took the practice tests.  I spent thousands of dollars on review materials, travel, hotels, and the tests themselves.  I didn't get the highest scores, but I passed every single test the first time. 

RESIDENCY
 - It finally happened.  I got to the point where I can read a book and understand the material and remember it.  I now have 4 kids and a very busy position in my church.  I really don't have time to get together for study groups.  So I read.  I have a book with me EVERYWHERE.  I have one at work to read between appointments.  I take one to the DMV while I wait in line, read it on my lunch breaks, and keep one on my night stand to read before going to bed.
That way I can always play with my kids, and when they move on to something else - I can read. 

Why do I mention all of this?  Today I spoke with a sophomore in college whose grades are slipping.  He told me "I've never had to study and I just don't really know how."

This is what I told him.  You start by looking for new solutions.  You go to the tutoring center, you ask people if you can study with them, you make routines and schedules, you find a way.

I didn't make it through school unscathed.  I never had a 4.0 in high school or college.  I almost failed a course in med-school (the week after my 2nd baby was born).  I am not the smartest, or the brightest.  I'm smart "enough," and I learned how to study.  That is the "secret" of my success.